AI Video Scripts: Why Generic Drafts Lose Viewers and How to Make Them Specific
AI tools can draft a script in seconds. The trouble is that a first draft often sounds like everyone else's: broad claims, stock phrases, and no real detail. Viewers notice, and they swipe.
Why generic scripts underperform
A generic script tends to:
- open with a broad statement ("In today's fast-paced world..."),
- list tips without examples,
- avoid anything specific enough to be checked or remembered.
In short-form video, every second gives the viewer another chance to leave. Your retention graph in YouTube Studio or your platform's analytics shows where viewers leave. Look closely and you'll often find a generic line sitting right where the curve dips.
Give the AI better inputs
What you get out depends on what you put in. Before asking for a script, give the tool:
- Who the viewer is and what problem they have.
- One specific point the video must make.
- Your real example: a result you saw, a mistake you made, a product detail.
- Your voice: paste a paragraph you wrote so the tool can match it.
- The length: for example, 30 seconds, about 65 to 80 spoken words.
Edit the draft in three passes
Pass 1: cut. Delete the first sentence if it's a warm-up. Remove any line that would be true of any video on the topic. If a stranger could have written it without knowing you, it goes.
Pass 2: specify. Replace broad claims with details. "Lighting matters" becomes "Face the window, not the lamp."
Pass 3: say it out loud. Read the script aloud with a timer. Rewrite anything you stumble on. If it trips you up, it will trip up the viewer too.
Check facts the AI adds
AI tools can produce confident but wrong statements, including invented statistics and citations. Don't publish a number or quote unless you can find its original source. The Federal Trade Commission has warned businesses that claims about products and results must be truthful and substantiated, and that applies whether a person or a tool wrote the words.
Script structure that holds attention
- Hook (first 1 to 2 seconds): the problem or the payoff.
- Proof or demo: show it working on screen.
- Steps: two or three, not ten.
- Close: one clear next action.
How long a script should be
Short video scripts are usually planned by time, not by word count, but word count is the easiest way to check. A common rule of thumb is that people speak at roughly 130 to 160 words per minute in conversation, though pace varies a lot from speaker to speaker, so time yourself reading the script aloud. At a conversational pace, that works out to roughly:
- 15 seconds: about 33 to 40 words
- 30 seconds: about 65 to 80 words
- 60 seconds: about 130 to 160 words
Read the draft out loud with a timer. If you rush to fit it, cut words instead of speaking faster. YouTube now counts vertical or square videos of up to three minutes as Shorts, but a longer limit is permission, not a target. Many ideas work best at the shortest length that still delivers the point.
Write for the ear and the screen at once
A short video script has two tracks: what is said and what is shown. Generic drafts usually describe only the spoken track. Add a simple second column for visuals and on screen text, line by line:
| Spoken | On screen |
|---|---|
| "Your lighting is the problem, not your camera." | Side by side: dim shot, window lit shot |
| "Turn so the window is in front of you." | Arrow toward window |
| "That one change did more than any filter." | Text: "Face the window" |
Writing the visual column forces specificity. It is hard to write "show something engaging." It is easy to write "show the before and after."
Prompts that produce less generic drafts
Four prompt habits help:
- Ask for options, not one answer. "Give me five different opening lines for this idea, each under 12 words." Pick the best and discard the rest.
- Ban the stock phrases. Tell the tool not to use openers such as "In today's world" or "Have you ever wondered," and not to end with "Like and subscribe."
- Supply the proof. Paste the real example, result or detail you want included, and tell the tool not to invent statistics or case studies.
- Ask it to cut. After the first draft, ask for a version 30 percent shorter. The second draft is often the stronger one.
Disclose AI where the platform asks
Using AI to draft a script does not by itself require a label. YouTube says it does not require disclosure when generative AI is used for productivity, such as generating scripts, content ideas or automatic captions. Disclosure is required for realistic synthetic media, such as a synthetic voice narrating as a real person or a realistic scene that did not happen. If your script is read by an AI voice clone or an avatar of a real person, check each platform's rules before posting.
Build a reusable brief
Once a script works, save the inputs that produced it: the viewer description, the single point, the real example, your voice sample and the length. That short brief becomes a template for the next video. Over time you will notice which kinds of examples keep viewers watching, and you can ask the tool for more of those. You aren't chasing a perfect prompt. You're building a repeatable process where the AI handles the first draft and you supply what only you know.
A quick before-and-after
Generic: "Captions are important for engagement. Make sure to add captions to your videos."
Specific: "Most of my viewers watch on mute. Here is the caption style I use so they can follow every word."
The second version gives a reason, a point of view, and a promise. The first one could sit in anyone's video.
Before you record your next video, read the script out loud once and ask whether it sounds like a person or a template. If it sounds like a template, rewrite the opening until it doesn't.
Sources
- YouTube Help, "Measure key moments for audience retention": https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/9314415
- Federal Trade Commission, "Keep your AI claims in check" (Business Blog, 2023): https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/blog/2023/02/keep-your-ai-claims-check
- Federal Trade Commission, Advertising FAQs: A Guide for Small Business: https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/advertising-faqs-guide-small-business
- YouTube Blog, "How we're helping creators disclose altered or synthetic content" (March 18, 2024): https://blog.youtube/news-and-events/disclosing-ai-generated-content/
- YouTube Help, "Understand three-minute YouTube Shorts": https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/15424877
- TikTok Help Center, "AI-generated content": https://support.tiktok.com/en/using-tiktok/creating-videos/ai-generated-content