How to Track Which Video Formats Are Actually Growing Your Channel
Most creators make several kinds of videos: tutorials, behind the scenes clips, reactions, trend videos, talking head opinions. Some of those formats probably grow your channel more than others. The trouble is that one viral video can hide the pattern, and gut feeling is easy to fool. A simple tracking system shows which formats are really doing the work on your channel, with your audience.
There is no universal ranking of formats. Any table that says one format always gets a certain engagement rate is guessing. Here, your own numbers are the only ones that count.
Step 1: Name your formats
Make a short list of the formats you post, and give each a consistent label. For example:
- Tutorial
- Behind the scenes
- Reaction
- Trend or challenge
- Opinion or commentary
- Product demo
Keep the list short, usually four to six labels. If a video fits two, pick the one that best describes the main idea.
Step 2: Decide what growth means
Pick a few metrics that show real growth, not just a passing glance. Useful ones include:
- Followers or subscribers gained from each video
- Average view duration or average watch time
- Completion, the share of viewers who watched to the end
- Shares and saves
- Returning viewers, where the platform reports them
Views alone are a weak measure, and definitions change. YouTube, for example, says that starting March 31, 2025, Shorts views count each time a Short starts to play or replay, while a separate engaged views metric remains available in YouTube Analytics. Write down which definitions you're using so your records stay comparable.
Step 3: Find the numbers in each platform
- YouTube. YouTube Studio shows views, watch time, subscribers gained and audience retention for each video. The retention report shows where viewers stop watching.
- TikTok. TikTok's analytics show video views, average watch time, watched full video, and followers gained for individual posts.
- Instagram. Professional accounts can see insights for each Reel, including views and interactions.
Each platform's help center explains exactly what its metrics mean. Read those definitions once. They aren't the same from app to app.
Step 4: Build a simple log
Use a spreadsheet with one row per video and these columns:
- Date posted
- Platform
- Format label
- Length in seconds
- Views (with your chosen definition)
- Average watch time
- Completion percentage
- Followers or subscribers gained
- Shares and saves
- Notes, such as the topic or anything unusual like a paid boost
Record each video's numbers at the same age, for example seven days after posting, so newer and older videos are compared fairly.
Step 5: Compare formats, not videos
After you have at least several videos in each format, usually a month or two of posting, calculate averages or medians by format:
- Median followers gained per video
- Median completion
- Median shares per thousand views
The median, the middle value, is often better than the average because one viral video can drag the average far from the typical result.
Look for formats that do well again and again, not ones that had one big hit.
Step 6: Run deliberate tests
Once you see a pattern, test it on purpose.
- Change one thing at a time. Try the same topic as a tutorial and as an opinion video, rather than changing topic, length and format all at once.
- Keep the schedule steady so posting time doesn't distort the result.
- Give each test enough videos. One or two videos per format aren't enough to judge.
- Write down what you expected before you look at the results. It keeps you from fooling yourself.
Step 7: Act on what you learn
At the end of each month:
- Make more of the format that consistently brings followers and strong completion.
- Rework the weakest format, or drop it if it keeps underperforming.
- Note any format that drives shares but not follows. It may be good for reach and worth pairing with a clear reason to follow.
Common mistakes
- Chasing one viral video. Outliers happen. Look at medians across many videos.
- Comparing raw views across platforms. Each platform counts differently. Compare formats within a platform.
- Changing everything at once. If you switch topic, length and format together, you can't tell which change mattered.
- Ignoring paid boosts. Mark promoted videos and leave them out of organic comparisons.
How much data is enough
Before you judge a format, wait until you have several videos in it, posted over more than one week, and compare them with a similar number of videos in your other formats. A single breakout can make a format look better than it is, and a single flop can bury a good one. If a format only has two or three videos, mark it as still being tested in your log.
Separate the format from the topic
A format can look strong because of the topics you happened to use it for. If every tutorial covered a trending subject and every story video covered an old one, you are measuring the topic, not the format. When you can, try the same topic in two formats a few weeks apart, and note the topic in your log so you can sort by it later.
Watch for counting changes
Because of the Shorts views change in Step 2, Shorts views before and after March 31, 2025 are not a clean comparison. Add a note in your log on the date of any counting change you learn about, and compare formats within the same period.
A monthly review routine
Once a month, sort your log by format and look at the median result for each, not the best one. Then write three short lines: the format to make more of, the format to change and the format to pause. Keep those notes, because after a few months they show whether your decisions are actually moving the numbers you chose in Step 2.
Where that leaves you
The formats that grow your channel are the ones your own data says grow it. Label your videos, log a few meaningful metrics at the same age, compare formats by their medians and test deliberately. A month or two of honest tracking will teach you more than any general ranking can.
Start the spreadsheet this week, even if it only has a few rows at first.
Sources
- YouTube Help, "Get started creating YouTube Shorts" (includes the March 31, 2025 views counting change): https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/10059070
- YouTube Help, "Measure key moments for audience retention": https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/9314415
- TikTok Help Center, "Creator tools on TikTok" (TikTok Studio analytics): https://support.tiktok.com/en/using-tiktok/creating-videos/creator-tools-on-tiktok
- TikTok Newsroom, "TikTok Tutorial Series: TikTok Analytics" (per video views, average watch time and audience data): https://newsroom.tiktok.com/product-tutorial-tiktok-analytics?lang=en
- Instagram Help Center, "Reel size and aspect ratios on Instagram": https://help.instagram.com/1038071743007909